Muktomona Debate:Is Homosexuality similar to Pedophilia?

The writer ha pre-notioned beliefs that HOMOSEXUALITY is infact a MENTAL DISORDER and tries to equate it with PEDOPHILIA

 

WRT: http://groups.yahoo.com/group/mukto-mona/message/31558

I agree with you. Homosexuality is a mental disorder. I am not thinking from
religious point of view. Those who think that homosexuality is natural and
should be approved by all, for those let me tell you one thing: if the
pedophilic people say that pedophilia is a normal sexual act will you
approve that?
If a homosexual man finds you attractive will you let him to
have sex with you? You can pretend to be open minded by making arguments but
you have to be logical. Well this is solely my opinion. I don’t want to hurt
anyone. If you are happy to sleep with another man, be happy with that. Just
don’t try to motivate others to do the same.

Regards

Mohammad Nazir Hossain

CHEGUEVARA28 justifies to Md. Nazir Hossain that Homosxuality cannot be placed in the same Bracket of PEDOPHILIA

WRT: http://groups.yahoo.com/group/mukto-mona/message/31597

“MOHAMMAD NAZIR HOSSAIN” wrote:
> I agree with you. Homosexuality is a mental disorder. I am not
thinking from
> religious point of view.

Those who think that homosexuality is natural and
> should be approved by all, for those let me tell you one thing: if the
> pedophilic people say that pedophilia is a normal sexual act will you
> approve that?

Homosexuality exists in nature. Whether or not you accept it — it
wont change.

I do not view pedophilia as the same as homosexuality… there are
different sexual orientations…

Heterosexuality is an orientation towards opposite gender.
Homosexuality is an orientation towards the same gender. It has
nothing to do with the age of a person just the gender… Pedophilia
is an orientation towards a certain age group. So homosexuality does
not fall in the same category as pedophilia.

Pedophilia in action is rape. However, two consenting adults of the
same gender having sex is not rape.

Similarly zoophilia, another type of sexual orientation, is totally
different from hetero and homo and pedo since it is an orientation
towards a different species altogether. This could also be considered
as rape…

You cannot put all the other types (other than heterosexual) of
sexuality in the same box (e.g., homosexuality and pedophilia in the
same box) just because you do not like homosexuality. Someone who does
not like heterosexuality may put heterosexuality in the same box with
pedophilia… how would you like that?

Well since it is a question of gender — the same or opposite… these
two (homo and heterosexual) can be put in the same box labeled Gender
Orientation or something like that. However, homosexuality and
pedophilia are totally different.

>If a homosexual man finds you attractive will you let him to
> have sex with you? You can pretend to be open minded by making
arguments but
> you have to be logical.

If any heterosexual member of the opposite sex finds you attractive…
do you let that “any” person have sex with you?

And if a heterosexual person finds a homosexual person attractive
should that homosexual person (if s/he is not bisexual) just have sex
with the heterosexual person? Think of these things. Be fair in your
thinking.

So where is your logic?


Well this is solely my opinion. I don’t want to hurt
> anyone. If you are happy to sleep with another man, be happy with
that. Just
> don’t try to motivate others to do the same.

It is okay for you to deride homosexuality and wrong for homosexuals
to promote homosexuality or for open minded heterosexuals to point out
that it exists in nature?

Che

Advertisements

2 Comments

Filed under Analysis of Homosexual Issues

2 responses to “Muktomona Debate:Is Homosexuality similar to Pedophilia?

  1. Adam Fairbanks

    I completely agree with Che, your points are stunningly accurate.

    In addition, it is not as if homosexuals are trying to spread homosexuality, or force heterosexuals to engage in homosexual activity. Personally, I merely hope that we may all live in peace and accept one another as the human beings that we are.

    I am content to live my life with another man, just as I hope that any heterosexual is happy to live his or her life beside a woman or man (respectively). I also hope that every homosexual man or woman is lucky enough to have the right to live their lives with another man or woman (also respectively). That is my only wish.

    • june

      I understand that there is a difference between pedophilia and homosexuality. However, I feel the arguments that have helped me reject pedophilia are the same that make me reject homosexuality. Basically, these are that just because I consent and do not feel adverse to sex with another does not make it a moral relationship. It requires mature thinking to understand a lifelong commitment based on what our bodies are fitted for, and a mature body to fully experience it. Just because Jane Goodall saw apes consuming their infants does not make it a perfectly fine way to behave for humans as far as I know. Whatever we do with our bodies needs to be done with love.. I do not advocate a sudden hatred for those parts of us that are special.. homosexual, heterosexual, whatever ..at all. Really, most of it is none of my business.. but these sort of discussions are fantastic for developing inner dialogue also

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s